Address
234 Lower Gilmore Rd
Campton KY 41301
Work Hours
Monday to Friday: 9AM - 5PM
nnnnn
Skip to content
The things that destroy real estate deals in our region are the things you can't see on a map.
TL;DR: Eastern Kentucky properties—especially in mining areas like Belfry, Betsy Layne, and McDowell—carry invisible legal complications: severed mineral rights, clouded heirship chains, unrecorded easements, and century-old coal company agreements. These “legal landmines” aren’t visible on surveys or inspections. Only experienced title attorneys who understand Kentucky property law, mining history, and generational ownership patterns can uncover and resolve them before they explode your transaction.
You just bought your dream property in Floyd County. Five beautiful acres with a creek running through it, mountain views, and room for your kids to run. The survey looks perfect. The inspection was clean. You signed the papers, got the keys, and moved in.
Six months later, a coal company shows up with bulldozers and easement documents from 1952 giving them the right to build a haul road straight through what you thought was your backyard. The legal description is clear. The rights were severed decades before you were born. And there’s absolutely nothing you can do about it except watch heavy equipment tear up your property.
Or maybe you’re trying to sell that family land in Pike County that’s been in your name for three years. Except the title company discovers that the deed from 1974 doesn’t actually convey ownership to you—it conveys it to “The Heirs of John Smith,” and now you need to track down twelve different grandchildren scattered across four states, get them all to sign off, and pray none of them decide to challenge the distribution.
Or perhaps you’ve been using that driveway to reach your house in McDowell for fifteen years when suddenly your neighbor—new owners who just moved in—put up a gate and inform you there’s no recorded easement giving you the right to cross their property. Your only access to your own home just disappeared because someone seventy years ago did a handshake deal instead of recording proper paperwork.
Welcome to Eastern Kentucky real estate, where the biggest problems aren’t termites or foundation cracks—they’re invisible legal complications buried in deed books, coal company agreements, probate records, and century-old mineral severance documents that no property inspection or survey will ever reveal.
After decades of combined legal experience handling real estate transactions across Pike County, Floyd County, and the coalfields of Eastern Kentucky, we can tell you this with absolute certainty: the things that destroy real estate deals in our region are the things you can’t see on a map.
A legal landmine is any title defect, ownership complication, or property rights issue that isn’t immediately obvious from physical inspection but can destroy property value, prevent transactions, or create years of legal battles.
These aren’t hypothetical problems. These are issues we encounter regularly in Pike County, Floyd County, and throughout Eastern Kentucky’s mining regions:
Surface ownership separated from subsurface rights, often giving coal companies or mineral rights holders extensive control over “your” property.
Properties that passed through generations without proper estate settlement, creating ownership uncertainty and requiring complex heirship research.
Driveways, utilities, and access routes established through handshake agreements that were never formally documented.
Historical mining rights, haul road easements, and coal extraction agreements that remain valid decades after mines closed.
Deed descriptions referencing “the old oak tree” or “the creek bed” that create ambiguity about actual property lines.
Judgment liens, tax liens, and business debt that attached to property and were never properly released.
These problems are especially common in Eastern Kentucky because:
Our region’s mining heritage created complex property rights structures that don’t exist in areas without coal extraction history. Mineral severance was standard practice from the 1890s through the 1970s, affecting thousands of properties.
Generational property ownership is the norm. Land has often been in the same family for 50, 75, even 100 years, passing through multiple generations with varying levels of formal documentation.
Informal arrangements were culturally acceptable. Handshake deals, family agreements, and gentleman’s understandings were how business was done—creating problems now when formal documentation is required.
Economic challenges affected record-keeping. When times were tough, families sometimes couldn’t afford attorneys to properly settle estates or record documents, leaving gaps in the chain of title.
Geographic isolation limited access to legal services. In areas where the nearest attorney was 30 miles away and road access was limited, formal legal procedures were often skipped.
As John puts it, “Every deed in Eastern Kentucky tells a story. Sometimes it’s a simple story with a clear beginning and end. But often it’s more like a novel with missing chapters, and our job is to figure out what happened in between.”
Every deed in Eastern Kentucky tells a story. Sometimes it’s a simple story with a clear beginning and end. But often it’s more like a novel with missing chapters, and our job is to figure out what happened in between.
John Holder

Let us walk you through three situations we’ve handled that demonstrate exactly how these invisible problems surface—and how they’re resolved when you have experienced title attorneys who understand Eastern Kentucky property law.
A buyer in Floyd County found the perfect property for their business: three acres with good road frontage in a growing area. The seller had owned it for decades, seemed eager to sell, and the price was reasonable.
During our title examination, we discovered a problem. The current “owner” had never actually received clear title. The property had been conveyed in 1974 through a deed that read: “To John Smith and upon his death to his heirs.”
John Smith died in 1989 without a will. The property was never formally probated. John’s children simply continued paying property taxes and assumed they owned it. When one of those children—our seller—decided to sell the property, they believed they had the right to do so.
But legally? The property belonged to “The Heirs of John Smith,” which required identifying all legal heirs and obtaining proper conveyance from each one.
Our research identified:
Clearing this title required:
The transaction eventually closed, but only because we had the legal expertise and the patience to untangle fifty years of incomplete probate. A title company without attorney leadership would have simply declared the title “unmarketable” and walked away.
This scenario is common in Eastern Kentucky because informal family arrangements—”Dad left the land to all of us kids”—seemed perfectly reasonable until someone tried to sell. The problem isn’t the families. The problem is that property law requires formal documentation that didn’t exist.

A young couple purchased a beautiful 50-acre property in Pike County. Rolling hills, mature trees, a stream running through it—everything they’d dreamed of for raising their family.
The deed clearly conveyed “50 acres, more or less” with a legal description matching the survey. The title insurance policy listed a mineral severance from 1948, which the buyers acknowledged. They understood that a coal company owned the mineral rights, but the mine had been closed since the 1980s. They assumed the severance was a historical footnote.
Three years after purchase, the couple received notice from a coal company: they were exercising their rights under the 1948 mineral severance to access coal reserves through surface operations. The severance agreement included broad language giving the coal company the right to:
The couple was devastated. Their “50 acres” was about to become an active mining site with heavy equipment, coal trucks, and constant industrial activity.
They called us in a panic, hoping we could stop it. The hard truth? Everything the coal company was doing was legal and clearly documented in the 1948 severance agreement that had been recorded in the Pike County Clerk’s office for 75 years.
The mineral severance was disclosed on the title insurance policy, but neither the buyers nor their previous title company had fully explained what it meant. “Severed mineral rights” sounded like an abstract legal concept. They didn’t understand it meant a coal company could literally return decades later and transform their property into an industrial site.
We reviewed their title insurance policy and the original severance documents. The policy correctly disclosed the severance but did not cover the surface damage—that’s standard in title insurance. The buyers had no legal recourse against the coal company.
Our work shifted to damage control and negotiation:
The outcome wasn’t what the buyers wanted. The coal company proceeded with operations, though they agreed to reasonable limitations on haul road placement. The buyers ultimately sold the property at a significant loss and purchased elsewhere.
This is Eastern Kentucky’s most painful legal landmine: severed mineral rights that give companies extraordinary control over surface land. It’s legal. It’s documented. And unless you understand what you’re buying, it’s devastating.
As Lindon explains, “Mineral severance in Eastern Kentucky isn’t just a footnote in a deed—it’s a fundamental restructuring of property rights that most buyers don’t understand until it’s too late.”
Mineral severance in Eastern Kentucky isn’t just a footnote in a deed—it’s a fundamental restructuring of property rights that most buyers don’t understand until it’s too late.
Lindon Gullett
A property in McDowell had been accessed by the same driveway for forty years. The driveway crossed a neighbor’s land for about 300 feet before reaching the property. Everyone knew it. Everyone accepted it. It had always been that way.
The property changed hands several times over those forty years. Each time, the driveway access was mentioned verbally but never formally documented. No easement was ever recorded. The arrangement existed purely on neighborly goodwill and historical practice.
Then the neighboring property sold to new owners from out of state. The new neighbors, exercising their legal property rights, installed a gate across the driveway and informed our client that they had no legal right to cross the property.

Our client was trapped. Their home was landlocked without the driveway. They couldn’t sell (no buyer would purchase a landlocked property). They couldn’t access their own home without trespassing. And legally, the neighbors were correct—there was no recorded easement.
We researched the property history thoroughly:
Our research uncovered something useful: the original property had been divided in 1967, and both parcels were owned by the same person at that time. When property is divided and one parcel becomes landlocked, Kentucky law sometimes implies an easement by necessity. The question was whether that implied easement survived multiple subsequent transfers.
We filed a quiet title action seeking to establish a legal easement across the neighbor’s property based on:
The litigation took eighteen months and cost our client $12,000 in legal fees. Ultimately, the court ruled in our client’s favor, establishing a formal easement and requiring it to be properly recorded. But the neighborly relationship was destroyed, and the financial and emotional cost was significant.
This situation could have been prevented if someone—at any point in forty years—had properly recorded an easement agreement. But handshake deals and informal arrangements are deeply embedded in Eastern Kentucky culture, and legal documentation often feels unnecessary until a conflict arises.
Our region’s coal mining history left behind a legal framework that complicates nearly every property transaction in Pike County, Floyd County, and surrounding areas.
Understanding this history is essential to understanding why Eastern Kentucky real estate is different:
During the coal boom, mineral rights were systematically separated from surface rights across thousands of properties. Coal companies and mineral speculators purchased subsurface rights while landowners retained surface ownership.
These severances were often:
The result: a massive portion of Eastern Kentucky property has split ownership, with surface rights held by homeowners and mineral rights held by coal companies, investment groups, or mineral estates that have passed through multiple owners.
Many mineral severances used “broad form” language that gave mineral rights holders not just the right to extract minerals, but also:
Kentucky’s legislature eventually restricted broad form deeds through the 1988 Broad Form Deed Amendment to the state constitution, but this doesn’t invalidate severances created before 1988—it just limits future severances. Historical broad form deeds remain enforceable.
Just because a mine closed in 1975 doesn’t mean the mineral rights expired. Mineral severances typically don’t have time limits. A coal company can return decades later and resume operations if economically viable coal remains.
Properties near historical mining operations may also have:
Surface mining (strip mining) became common in the 1960s-70s. Many mineral severances written before this era didn’t anticipate surface mining’s extensive impact. Courts have wrestled with balancing mineral owners’ extraction rights against surface owners’ property rights, with results that vary depending on specific deed language.
As John notes, “You can’t understand Eastern Kentucky property law without understanding coal. Every complication we see—the severances, the easements, the access disputes—traces back to mining. It’s not ancient history. It’s current reality affecting property values and transactions today.”
Based on decades of combined experience handling closings throughout Eastern Kentucky’s coalfields, these are the title complications we encounter most frequently:
The Problem:
Property passed through one or more generations without proper estate settlement. The deed identifies owners as “heirs” or contains language like “to John Smith and his heirs” without specifying exactly who those heirs are.
Why It Happens:
Probate costs money. In tight economic times, families often skip formal probate and simply continue using property with the assumption that “everybody knows” who owns it. This works fine until someone tries to sell or mortgage the property.
How We Resolve It:
Time Required:
3-12 months depending on complexity
Cost Range:
$2,000-$15,000 in legal fees
The Problem:
Surface ownership is separated from subsurface mineral rights, creating split ownership with mineral rights holders having extensive (sometimes dominant) rights over the property.
Why It Happens:
Historical coal industry practices systematically separated mineral rights from surface rights across thousands of Eastern Kentucky properties, particularly from the 1890s through 1970s.
How We Resolve It:
Key Point:
Severed mineral rights can’t usually be “fixed”—they’re legal property interests. Our job is ensuring buyers fully understand what they’re purchasing and the risks involved.
The Problem:
Property access relies on driveways, roads, or paths crossing neighboring land without formal recorded easements. These arrangements exist through long-standing practice, neighborly goodwill, or verbal agreements.
Why It Happens:
Eastern Kentucky culture historically valued handshake deals and trusted relationships over formal legal documentation. Recording easements cost money and seemed unnecessary when “everybody knew” how things worked.
How We Resolve It:
Time Required:
2 weeks to 24 months depending on cooperation
Cost Range:
$500 (simple recorded easement) to $20,000+ (contested litigation)
The title insurance industry has increasingly moved toward automation, using software systems to process routine transactions with minimal human review. This works fine for newer suburban properties with clean title histories.
It fails catastrophically in Eastern Kentucky.
Here’s why computer systems can’t handle our region’s title complications:
Automated title searches can flag a mineral severance or an unclear heir designation. But they can’t:
A software system sees “to John Smith and his heirs” and flags it as a problem. An experienced Kentucky attorney understands the historical and cultural context of that language, knows Kentucky probate law, can identify the most efficient path to resolution, and has handled dozens of similar situations.
Is this mineral severance a deal-breaker or manageable risk? Does this unclear boundary description create real problems or is it resolvable through surveying? Should we pursue quiet title litigation or negotiate with the parties? These require legal expertise and experience—not algorithms.
Resolving complex title issues often requires coordination with county clerks, PVA offices, probate courts, and other local institutions. We know these people. We understand their processes. We can call and get answers. A computer system in California can’t.
Clearing title defects involves analyzing property law, researching case precedent, drafting legal documents, negotiating with parties, and sometimes litigating disputes. This is attorney work, requiring attorney expertise and judgment.
As Lindon explains, “Title software is a tool, not a solution. It’s like the difference between WebMD and an actual doctor. WebMD can tell you that you have symptoms. A doctor can diagnose what’s wrong and prescribe treatment. We’re the doctors.”
Not every property in Pike or Floyd County has severe title complications, but certain characteristics increase the likelihood:
If you see multiple red flags, you need experienced title attorneys—not an automated title system or a national company processing transactions from another state.
Our process for handling complex title issues combines legal expertise, local knowledge, and genuine commitment to finding solutions:
We don’t just run automated searches. We examine:
This deep examination uncovers problems that automated systems miss.
When we identify title defects, we don’t just report them—we analyze them and develop resolution strategies:
We don’t hand you a problem and wish you luck. We actively work to resolve title defects:
We explain complex title issues in plain English:
As John puts it, “Our job isn’t just clearing title—it’s making sure clients understand exactly what they’re buying and what risks they’re accepting.”
We issue title insurance policies backed by Stewart Title’s financial strength, with:
Whether you’re buying property in Pike County, Floyd County, or anywhere in Eastern Kentucky’s coalfields, here’s how to protect yourself:
National title companies processing Eastern Kentucky transactions from offices in Nashville, Columbus, or Charlotte can run automated title searches and issue insurance policies. What they can’t do is:
Understand the historical context of mineral severances, coal company agreements, and generational property ownership that shaped our region’s legal landscape.
Navigate relationships with county clerks, PVA offices, local attorneys, and courthouse staff who hold the keys to resolving complex title issues.
Interpret unclear deed descriptions that reference local landmarks, family names, and historical boundaries that only make sense to people who know the area.
Negotiate with local parties involved in title disputes, easement conflicts, and heirship issues—people who respond better to attorneys they know and trust.
Apply Kentucky property law properly to unique situations that require legal expertise, not just template documents and standard procedures.
Provide hands-on problem resolution instead of just identifying issues and declaring title “unmarketable.”
We’re attorneys first, title agents second. We’re Eastern Kentucky residents who understand the culture, history, and legal frameworks that make our region unique. We’re backed by Stewart Title’s institutional strength while maintaining the local accountability and expertise that actually matter.
When your property has legal landmines buried in 100 years of deed books, you need more than software and standardized processes. You need experienced Kentucky attorneys who’ve cleared hundreds of complicated titles and know exactly what they’re looking at when they open those dusty deed books in the Pike County or Floyd County Clerk’s office.
About Eastern KY Title: Our team combines legal expertise, local knowledge, and a commitment to client protection. Led by Market President John Holder and President Lindon Gullett (both licensed Kentucky attorneys), we deliver secure, accurate, and stress-free real estate closings for families, lenders, and real estate professionals across Eastern Kentucky.
Our Team:
Professional Credentials:
Protect your investment with title examination that goes beyond automated searches—led by experienced Kentucky attorneys who understand our region’s unique property complications.
Call us today at (606) 226-0024 or email info@easternkytitle.com to discuss your property transaction. We serve Pike County, Floyd County, and all of Eastern Kentucky with comprehensive title services backed by attorney expertise and Stewart Title’s financial strength.
Because the things you can’t see on a map are the things that matter most.
Best regards,
Eastern KY Title Team
FULL DISCLOSURE: We use AI to draft our blog content because, frankly, we’d rather spend our time closing deals and helping Kentucky realtors than staring at blank screens. But don’t worry, we’re not letting the robots run wild. John and Lindon edit every single post to make sure it’s factually accurate, Kentucky-specific, and doesn’t sound like it was written by someone who thinks Appalachia is a type of pasta. If the AI writes something dumb, we fix it. If you spot something we missed, call us out. We’re good for it.